I never attended Hillsdale College but I did live in Hillsdale, Michigan for a time when I was younger. An absolutely beautiful place!
Glad to see St. Vincent College (#16 on the list) as a newcomer. It has always been close and often included if it is a top 50 or top 60 list rather than just top 40. Beautiful campus and short drive from where I live and work.
Also new to the list is Southern Utah University (#32), located in the most conservative part of one of the most conservative states in the union. The student body is roughly 30% of the town.
Where in Hillsdale did you live, and when?