I’ve used Craigslist in the past and had no problem. In fact, I’ve had great success in the past with Craigslist. I decided to try Zillow because some people at work said that a lot of people were now using Zillow and they sent the listing around to hotpads and Trulia.
Since you used Zillow in the past, have you ever seen your post listed as pending on your listing edit page. Does pending mean it’s waiting to be posted?
That's really weird. I've only seen "pending" on my listings that have gone under contract. I've not seen it in any situation where it's been listed as a rental. If you'd like, you could send me the address and I can check it on my end to see what shows up...