[Godebert]

"4) The current rules are codified as Title 8 section 1401 that defines Nationals and Citizens at birth."

But NOT natural born Citizens. That is defined by natural law. No law of man (positive law) can change natural law.

[taxcontrol]

You claim that no law of man can change natural law. So explain the natural law that allows people to overthrow their monarch. Did that natural law exist before 1776? If so, where was it written? Didn’t King George have the natural law right to rule over America?

Again, the problem with natural law is that it is not codified and can be anything anyone wants it to be a the time.