[lee martell]

Who? What? When and Why?

What’s wrong with using Gitmo?
It’s ready made.
If we expect this of Israel, they will expect something from us in return.

[TheDandyMan]

We’ve given them billions in cash, weapons, and support. We’re giving Israel 40 billion more American taxpayer dollars. We stick up for them constantly on the international stage — although they have never given us anything in return or fought by our side, even when we’re in their own backyard. French, British, Polish, Romanian, German soldiers have fought and died by our side in Afghanistan and the ME — our “greatest ally” Israel forgot to come.

In the event of the OP’s never-going-to-happen scenario takin place, Israel would have to have brass balls the size of the moon to “expect something in return.”

[AltarThroneMonarchy]

“If we expect this of Israel, they will expect something from us in return.” Like moving our embassy to Jerusalem? Like sharing our military technology? Like billions of dollars in foreign aid?