[gymbeau]

Baker was best, but Tennant is a close second, IMNHO.

[DrGunsforHands]

The Peter Capaldi “Heaven Sent”/“Hell Bent”. episode was utterly amazing. That castle and that thing and just everything about it was perfect. Utterly brilliant. Wasn’t the biggest fan of Capaldi at first but his 2nd season was fantastic. Loved Tennant and thought Matt Smith was great as well. Was never a huge fan of Christopher Eccleston. Could tell he was just doing it for money and to pad his resume and that he didn’t actually like it that much. Jodie Whittaker has been a disappointment. She’s too nice and too upfront about what she’s thinking/planning. Too much politics as well. She just isn’t zany enough. The writing in the last two seasons has just kind of sucked.

[SuperLuminal]

My favorites, in order:

1. Baker (Dr #4)
2. Pertwee (Dr #3)
3. Tennant (Dr #10)
4. Smith (Dr #11)

Disliked the most, in order:

1. McCoy (Dr #7)
2. Davison (Dr #5)
3. McGann (Dr #8)
4. Capaldi (Dr #12)

Just on principle, I won't disgrace the Dr Who reputation by mentioning the current Dr...

Dr #69... (How else could she have gotten the part?)

[higgmeister]

I thought Christopher Eccleston was better for his ability to bring the franchise back.   The romance/sexual tension between Billie Piper and David Tennant was contrived and not canon from the original series.