My Christmas present from last year, although I got the Marlin. A slow bullet but it hits like a freight train when it gets there. The dedicated bear rounds are really impressive (at both ends of the gun). If the shooter does his job, the .45/70 will do its job on even the biggest bear on the planet. I can see why the .45/70 carbines are popular with Alaskan bear guides - a lot of fire power in a small package.
I have the 1895 Cowboy as well, and I love the longer barrel and the 9 round capacity also. Took two deer with it this year, using the 325 grain Hornady leverevolution for my buck, and a new round I wanted to try, made by Defender Ammo Co., 350g flat nose. Great ammo at a good price, if you’re like me and don’t reload Defender has about the best deals on 45/70 I’ve found so far, Vet owned, smaller company, good people to work with too.
My son has the Marlin. I have the Henry which looks awesome. Overall, I give the nod to the Marlin. I prefer the side port loading of the Marlin. It is certainly better if you ever find yourself in a quick load and shoot situation. With the longer barrel, I think it hits harder, too.