[jmacusa]

After over one hundred and fifty years I’d hate to think. And if the South had won the war would it have freed the slaves?

[Bull Snipe]

Not for a long time. As long as cash crop agriculture was profitable, slavery would have continued to exist in the Confederacy. It would have taken an Amendment to the Confederate Constitution to allow its member states to outlaw the institution.

[philman_36]

And if the South had won the war would it have freed the slaves?

Immediately at the end of the war? No, probably not.
Years after the war? Yes, probably so.
They would have been emancipated, IMO.
Since many slaves were field hands then mechanized farm equipment
would eventually make them too expensive to own/maintain.
Would you prefer a tractor or a mule?
Sorry if that sounds crass, but they were an asset/property at that time.

Does it offend you that someone has a different view than you of impossible things?

[philman_36]

Since you have a vision of what the South would be what is your vision of what the North would be?

After over one hundred and fifty years I’d hate to think.

You can't articulate your Northern States' post war vision, but you have no problem whatsoever pushing the Southern States' Slavery meme.

Telling.