[TheBigJ]

Look up the definition again.

Ad hominem means also questioning motive in case you wondered.

Otherwise, the rest of your post is rabid speculation and assumptions.

[bagster]

Let's not devolve into fighting about definitions.

Wingy was simply letting you know that it's not good to speculate on who Q really is.

I don't see that as questioning your motives, but rather the possible results, intended or otherwise, of your speculation.

It's really not worth fighting for, is it?

Please, TheBigJ, don't be discouraged from contributing. We need all hands on deck. Especially the feisty ones.

Wingy meant no harm. I had the same thought when I read your original post, as I do with all posts who attempt to identify Q. I was just too big a pusscakes to say anything.

Carry on, men. We have a nation to save.

Where we go one we go all.

[Wingy]

BigJ, you're just silly. It's not attacking motive as you state, it's attacking the motives of the person. I merely pointed out the consequences of that particular guessing game. I made no guess as to your motive. It looks like you lose again.

That's the end for me. Go somewhere else for the fight you crave.