they dated
Not according to her own account. She says that after CIC ended, she was dating a guy and didn’t want to be a virgin, so she called Baio and got him to take her virginity. She then told the interviewer that Baio then asked her if she wanted to go out for dinner, and she gave him a hard no and went off to her boyfriend. Her own description of the encounter, which by her account was long after CIC ended, making her well over the age of 18.
they both ate tomatoes, too