“I usually just chew on a burned band-aid when I need to replicate scotch flavor.”
If you are really into that flavor try LaPhroaig.
We had an Islay Island tasting a couple months ago and came a away with this description of LaPhroaig (we had two LaPhoaigs.)
“A young man not showered in a few days, after hiking in the woods starts a wet, smokey fire; and while sitting in the smoke, peels off the one-week old, large Band-Aid covering a bloody wound on his knee.”
Enjoy! LOL
Now, on the other had, Lagavulin. Oh, yea, nothing better. Maybe the Highland Park.