[IronJack]

I didn’t see anything in the movies that Peter Jackson added. He left some things out and rearranged a few minor events to make the stories break at a valid dramatic point, but I don’t see his fingerprints on the story itself.

[Tax-chick]

I didn’t see anything in the movies that Peter Jackson added.

Then we have no basis for discussion. Ne zot!

[Mr Rogers]

“I didn’t see anything in the movies that Peter Jackson added.”

Arwen as Wonder Woman in the first? Strider as self-doubting, not wanting to be king? Frodo turned into a whining weakling?

Jackson does action sequences. Character development is beyond him.