Hard to take seriously a baseball pundit who doesn’t know that Phil Rizzutto was a shortstop.
I agree with him on 3 of the 5, but I think the case can be made fairly strongly for Jim Rice based upon his prime seasons.
Also, Ozzie Smith was so extraordinary on defense that a solid case can be made. Defense should not just be an asterisk, although it is harder to compare players. But Ozzie Smith deserves the term “great”....