You know perfectly well that I meant that there is nothing specifically Catholic about the science of logic.
You pretend to think I was saying that a Catholic cannot be logical.
You display your profound intellectual dishonesty at every turn.
I should warn you that intellectual dishonesty is a sin for which men are damned.
Dude...I have no idea what you mean by the vast majority of your posts.
I'll repeat what I posted before. If we presume the catholic position of Mary being the "mother of God" is correct then the following is correct.
Mary is the mother of God
Holy Spirit is God
Mary is the mother of the Holy Spirit
Are you willing to agree to this?? This is the next "logical" position based on your "argument".
This foolishness could go on but the astute reader will understand why your pathetic attempt at "logic" fails.
The bible notes Mary is the mother of Jesus and that's what we should accept. Anything beyond that begins to become absurd and leads to very, very bad theology.
The catholic position has to have so many caveats and footnotes to explain away the plain meaning of your position.
Your position also mplies the following:
If Mary is the "mother of God", Mary existed prior to God.
We know that is not correct nor does the Bible sustain us the catholic understanding.
So no...it is your position that is intellectually dishonest for the false notion it advances. It is not sustained theologically...not that that matters to the catholic.
This is why Christians reject the title accorded to Mary by roman catholicism that she is the "mother of God".