If u join CarFox, do they still charge for each VIN search, or does the membership entitle you to a whole bunch of them?
One VIN is $39.99 and good for 60 days, 5 VIN reports is $49.99, and is also good for 60 days. The Unlimited CarFax reports is $54.99, also only good for 60 days, which, coincidentally, is what is selected as the default when you enter your payment information. This is what I suspect happened. OP wanted single VIN report for $39.99, but the default was unlimited for $54.99.