I can only speak for myself, Manning is a good man and a great Quarterback. But he should have quit after his first Superbowl loss with Denver. I know they won this year, but that was due to the defense’s work. Other then Sanders, we had no offense. They should have given Brock Osweiler more playing time, he is the future of the Broncos.
You mirror my thoughts. With the exception...I think he should have retired after his run in Indy. He could have gone out on top. No criticism...just lots of love.
I liken him to my Cowboys (yes I love the ‘boys) Nobody likes or loves a person or team that at one time did well with a good reputation.