Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Advisory Opinions: Forbidden Territory for Federal Courts
John Gomis ^ | 1/31/2014 | Law Street

Posted on 01/07/2016 9:48:30 AM PST by conservativejoy

Advisory opinions are essentially pieces of advice offered by courts as a way to provide guidance on a particular law or issue. Since its inception, the United States Supreme Court, and federal courts in general, have not been allowed to issue advisory opinions, even though some onlookers have speculated that they may help cut down work flow and clear up ambiguities in the law. Read on to learn about the history of advisory opinions, the Supreme Court’s ban on releasing them, and how that has affected our American jurisprudence system.

What Exactly is an Advisory Opinion?

An advisory opinion is a non-binding explanation of the legal implications of a situation that has not arisen in actual litigation. An advisory opinion allows the legislature, the executive branch, or a lower court to gain insight into the prevailing judicial interpretation of a law, regulation, or constitutional amendment. This reduces the likelihood that a governmental act will be invalidated for conflicting with the Constitution, so it could save time or money. Advisory opinions are not binding precedent but are often treated as persuasive if no other precedent exists.

Why Can't the Supreme Court Issue Advisory Opinions?

In the United States, federal courts are prohibited from issuing advisory opinions under Article III of the U.S. Constitution. Article III designates that any legal opinion promulgated by federal courts must pertain to an issue that is “mature for judicial resolution” and the parties must have a palpable interest in the case. Put more simply, the Supreme Court, or any lower federal courts, can only rule in a real case, not just when someone brings a topic to the court to ask for an opinion.

Partly at issue is the separation of powers.

Branches_US_gov

The job of the legislative branch is to make the laws, the executive branch is supposed to enforce them, and the judicial branch is supposed to interpret them. By allowing the judicial branch to interpret them earlier than is unnecessary, that separation becomes blurred. That’s the argument made by John Jay, the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, when he refused to offer judicial advice to President George Washington or Alexander Hamilton. Later, Justice William R. Day reinvigorated the argument against Supreme Court advisory opinions in Muskrat v. United States. He stated as a reason to not offer advisory opinions that:

The result will be that this court, instead of keeping within the limits of judicial power and deciding cases or controversies arising between opposing parties, as the Constitution intended it should, will be required to give opinions in the nature of advice concerning legislative action, a function never conferred upon it by the Constitution.

Are There Alternatives to Advisory Opinions?

Certain state courts allow federal courts and courts of other states to ask them certified questions about actual controversies involving the state’s law. The U.S. Supreme Court also accepts certified questions about actual controversies from lower federal courts; however, this is a rare occurrence. A certified question is a request from one court to another court for clarification of a question of law. For example, if a cause of action under a state statute is brought in federal court, the federal court may send a certified question to the state court in order to gain clarification about how to interpret the state statute in accordance with the state’s jurisprudence.

Federal courts are able to employ preventative adjudication in the form of declaratory judgments due to the passage of the Declaratory Judgment Act. A declaratory judgment is a legal finding of a party’s actual legal rights in an actual case or controversy (or lack thereof) against another party. These judgments are binding though they can be appealed. The act allows a party to seek a declaration of his or her rights against another party even if no specific legal relief is sought in the case. If the proven facts show that there is a possibility that relief may be warranted in the future, then the act gives federal courts the discretion to issue declaratory judgments that define parties’ rights.

Federal courts maintain artful legal doctrines in order to ensure that Declaratory Judgments do not amount to de-facto Advisory Opinions. These doctrines are codified in the case of Ashwander v. Tennessee Valley Authority. In that case, the U.S. Supreme Court promulgated specific guidelines for the use of Judicial Review: 1.The Court will not determine the constitutionality of legislation in nonadversary proceedings. 2.It will not anticipate a question of constitutional law. 3.It will not formulate a rule of constitutional law broader than needed. 4.It will not rule on constitutionality if there is another ground for deciding the case. 5.It will not determine a statute’s validity unless the person complaining has been injured by it. 6.It will not invalidate a statute at the instance of persons who have taken advantage of its benefits. 7.It will always ascertain whether any reasonable interpretation of a statute will allow it to avoid the constitutional issue.

These guidelines are designed to prevent courts from promulgating interpretations of the Constitution outside of a ruling in an actual case or controversy.

What is the Argument for Changing the Laws to Allow Federal Courts to Issue Advisory Opinions?

Proponents of granting the Supreme Court the power to issue advisory opinions argue that judicial economy will be improved by the ability to issue opinions more quickly about pervasive legal issues. They also argue that the government can avoid wasting time and resources investing in programs and policies only to have it all be for naught if the government’s action is held to be unconstitutional. Ten states allow their highest courts to issue advisory opinions and the mechanism is an effective legal procedure in those states.

What is the Argument for Maintaining the Status Quo?

Every tendency to deal with constitutional questions abstractly, to formulate them in terms of barren legal questions, leads to - sterile conclusions unrelated to actualities.

There are more expeditious and expedient means that government actors have for gaining necessary legal interpretations and findings from the courts, such as certified questions. Furthermore, there are procedural mechanisms that allow the legal status of a situation to be determined without the expense and difficulty of a full trial, such as declaratory judgments.


TOPICS: Society
KEYWORDS:

1 posted on 01/07/2016 9:48:30 AM PST by conservativejoy
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

This article was pointed out to me to refute Trump’s advice to Cruz. Cruz can hardly sue himself and advisory opinions are not allowed under our laws and the Constitution from federal courts.

I’d say this is pretty good evidence that Trump was NOT advised by attorneys on this as he claims.


2 posted on 01/07/2016 9:50:56 AM PST by conservativejoy (Pray Hard, Work Hard, Trust God ...We Can Elect Ted Cruz)
[ Post Reply]

To: BuckeyeTexan

SCOTUS.


3 posted on 01/07/2016 9:52:40 AM PST by Lurking Libertarian (Non sub homine, sed sub Deo et lege)
[ Post Reply]

To: Lurking Libertarian; Perdogg; JDW11235; Clairity; Spacetrucker; Art in Idaho; GregNH; Salvation; ...

FReepmail me to subscribe to or unsubscribe from the SCOTUS ping list.

4 posted on 01/07/2016 10:53:59 AM PST by BuckeyeTexan (There are those that break and bend. I'm the other kind. ~Steve Earle)
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

Trump suggested that Cruz obtain a declatory judgment in federal court, which is very different from an advisory opinion.

For a federal court to issue a declatory judgment, an actual, not a theoretical, case or controversy must exist. A challenge to Cruz’s eligibility has been filed in Vermont. Whether or not that qualifies as an actual case or controversy I can’t say.


5 posted on 01/07/2016 10:58:28 AM PST by BuckeyeTexan (There are those that break and bend. I'm the other kind. ~Steve Earle)
[ Post Reply]

To: BuckeyeTexan

Trump was suggesting Cruz take it to court. I was pointing out there would be no case that Cruz could bring. Several cases like the one you mentioned in Vermont have been filed and already dismissed.


6 posted on 01/07/2016 11:08:01 AM PST by conservativejoy (Pray Hard, Work Hard, Trust God ...We Can Elect Ted Cruz)
[ Post Reply]

To: BuckeyeTexan

Bfl


7 posted on 01/07/2016 11:14:21 AM PST by hoosiermama
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

No, Trump said Cruz should seek a declaratory judgment in federal court, which, again, is not the same as an advisory opinion. Cruz would not have to bring a case to obtain a declaratory judgment. He would have to demonstrate that an actual case or controversy already exists.


8 posted on 01/07/2016 11:34:59 AM PST by BuckeyeTexan (There are those that break and bend. I'm the other kind. ~Steve Earle)
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

Interesting, in light of the fact the Chief Justice Roy Moore of Alabama just released an advisory letter yesterday to all of the probate judges in his state concerning the ramifications of Obergefell.


9 posted on 01/07/2016 11:48:20 AM PST by EternalVigilance ('To secure the Blessings of Liberty to our Posterity.')
[ Post Reply]

To: EternalVigilance

A letter from a state justice to state judges has nothing to do with federal courts.


10 posted on 01/07/2016 12:02:24 PM PST by conservativejoy (Pray Hard, Work Hard, Trust God ...We Can Elect Ted Cruz)
[ Post Reply]

To: BuckeyeTexan

“A party seeking declaratory relief under the statute must present an “actual controversy” in order to satisfy the “case or controversy” requirement of Article III./11/ The Declaratory Judgment Act was not intended as a device for rendering mere advisory opinions. The case must involve a controversy that is substantial and concrete, must touch the legal relations of parties with adverse interests, and must be subject to specific relief through a decree of conclusive character./12/ Like any other federal court plaintiff, a claimant seeking relief under the Act must also satisfy the three requirements for constitutional standing./13/ Yet, even when a request for injunctive relief has become moot, declaratory relief has remained viable when an “immediate and definite” policy continues to affect a “present interest.”/14/

While the Act enlarges the range of remedies available to federal court litigants, it does not confer an independent basis for federal jurisdiction./15/ The Supreme Court described the Act as “procedural” in its operation and as intended simply to place another remedial arrow in the district court’s quiver./16/ Accordingly, any complaint seeking relief under the Act must invoke an independent basis for federal jurisdiction./17/”

http://www.federalpracticemanual.org/node/53

“While the Act enlarges the range of remedies available to federal court litigants, it does not confer an independent basis for federal jurisdiction”

I’m not a lawyer, but it looks like it would only apply to a federal case. No federal case exists, nor can Cruz initiate one. Just my reading as a lay person, though.


11 posted on 01/07/2016 12:13:10 PM PST by Mr Rogers (Can you remember what America was like in 2004?)
[ Post Reply]

To: Mr Rogers

That’s where I am also. I don’t see an actual case or controversy that would enable a declaratory judgment, but as you well know, IANAL. ;)


12 posted on 01/07/2016 12:46:02 PM PST by BuckeyeTexan (There are those that break and bend. I'm the other kind. ~Steve Earle)
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

Maybe you ought to read the article again. Advisory opinions from state courts are discussed.


13 posted on 01/07/2016 1:04:30 PM PST by EternalVigilance ('To secure the Blessings of Liberty to our Posterity.')
[ Post Reply]

To: EternalVigilance

The issue was that FEDERAL courts are prohibited from giving advisory opinions.


14 posted on 01/07/2016 2:04:18 PM PST by conservativejoy (Pray Hard, Work Hard, Trust God ...We Can Elect Ted Cruz)
[ Post Reply]

To: conservativejoy

So? I was pointing out a parallel in the news of last 24 hours. Chill out.


15 posted on 01/07/2016 2:43:26 PM PST by EternalVigilance ('To secure the Blessings of Liberty to our Posterity.')
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson