[rjsimmon]

But bad-assery aside, does anyone think that this may have been overkill?

Not really. The pastor had to make an exceptionally difficult call and that despite having attempted to help this man previously, his violent behaviour was not a direct threat to the congregation. Christ told his disciples that if they did not have a sword, sell their cloak and buy one. The pastor served his flock.

[rjsimmon]

his violent behaviour was not now a direct threat to the congregation.

Sorry, finger mis-appropriation...