Alas, I am no stranger to something like that "African Queen" sequence where Humphrey Bogart has to make a propeller in the jungle. Hint: Wooden mallet is best. Easy on the heat. Hump was working with iron.
In future, FReepers, refer all mechanical guru type questions to well ... a a a like, you know, guru. Take over GG!
Perhaps, just maybe - iffn you hadn’t used 180,000 psi steel rod when that piece of brass rod was hidin’, meybe the pin might not have kept on a grindin’ ‘til only the maufacturer and you knew which size that prop was when it left the factory.
Humor aside, the 7.5 air cooled could operate without the water pump retaining its vanes. All it did was pump enough water to keep the lower crankcase sear from reaching thermal destruction. It was a nice motor for pushing a flat bottomed canoe through the shallows west of Cockroach Bay.
Noisy, but could push through mud, algae, assorted ancestral habitats of Democrats.