He should be inducted... the day after he dies. Giamatti gave him a lifetime ban and that is exactly what it should be. Rose should never live to see himself in the Hall, but the day after he dies, he needs to be in there.
And your rationale for this is ?
As I understand it, no. He gave him an indefinite ban.
He said he would reconsider the decision in one year (which Rose assumed would be favorable). It opened the door for the owners to change the rules which they did not do.
Faye Vincent reconsidered the decision and did not alter it.