What a fantastic post. I applaud it, especially since I posted the thread in the first place. Now all that remains is that you somehow prove that ALL of the 14720 replications (more since then) were due to H202. If I were charitable to your claim, there would be about 20 experiments that involve H202 as the input that could account for the energy deltas, so that simply shows that you have 14700 more to go. Best of luck with that.