Ping
My 2¢:
Not well, considering that I started reading it twice, and gave up both times, after getting tired of trying to wade through it.
I’d rather see a short feature of Farmer Giles of Ham, or The adventures of Tom Bombadil. Even Smith of Wootton Major would be preferable.
That’d be awesome, but it would probably take more like a 6-9 film series to do properly (especially if the 2nd Age were also included-Numenor).
If they decided to do three films, like I’ve mentioned before, the would be best to break it down to three stories 1) The Tale of Beren and Luthien, The Children of Hurin, and The Fall of Gondolin.
Peter Jackson and Newline please..?
When I was still young and geeky enough to want to, I got it and read it, but it doesn’t have the big long story like the LOTR.