[Red in Blue PA]

Would say that if this woman walked into their living room and stole something of theirs

So you would just let someone waltz in and steal your things? Either that is utter BS or you are no man enough to guard and protect your home.

[wideawake]

No I wouldn't let her waltz in.

But I would dial 911 if I had the drop on her with my weapon, as opposed to killing or beating her.

There is a recurring belief on FR threads, unjustified by any Constitutional principle, that you can use deadly force against any intruder in any circumstance.