The problem is that NL 1B is so stacked this year. Votto and Goldschmidt have to be there, no question. I put Craig slightly ahead of Freeman. And Adrian Gonzalez would be a good choice, too. So there are five worthy, and two of those are locks.
Votto has a slightly better ba than freeman, but freeman has 15 more rbi’s.
He is also a better fielder.
Just looked it up:
Votto: 10 errors.
Freeman: 6 errors