Thanks..I don’t recall ever reading that..do you happen to have a link..or was the argument about why was a non US citizen even given a Miranda warning..
I'll give you my opinion here. Our rights our natural rights, therefore, given to all humans. So rights like protection from self-incrimination exist for citizen and non-citizen alike. In the case of Abdulmutallab or the case of Tsarnaev there is a reasonable belief that a crime (act of war?) is still ongoing so no Miranda right should even apply. This would be the same if a kidnapper is caught but the child is not found. That person should be questioned vigorously without any Miranda warning.