While I can’t weigh in on Selleck’s beefcake bonafides, I’ll say he is a gentleman and all around good guy. My father owned a limo company years back and he personally drove Selleck around one night on a Dallas visit...said he couldn’t be any nicer. This was crica 1990.
I’ve always heard that about Selleck too. I’ve also heard that Garner is not so nice. At least he seemed un-nice when he’d appear on programs like Johnny Carson. He seemed very angry at the studios. He claimed that he injured himself filming varous stunts. Probably true, but he was just all around angry.
But, they both were handsome guys in their youth. Selleck still is. Haven’t seen Garner since that movie he made with Sally Fields where he was a sour puss too,