That just means these companies aren't going to go bankrupt. It doesn't mean their P/E's can't end up well below 5 in a big downturn.
You are correct sir,
I find that a lot of people have no idea of what a “good” P/E number is.
Many simply think a low P/E is good and a high P/E is bad, or not as good.
The answer is: It depends.
Is the Company a growth company or an established so-called “blue chip”.
If it is an established company, then a low P/E may be a good opportunity to Buy.
If it is a growth company, then a low P/E is a problem.
I like to redefine P/E to read “Price Expectations” as opposed to “Price Earnings ratio”. A low P/E on a growth company would suggest investors have low expectations for this company, since they have not bid up the price. A high P/E for a growth company suggests that investors have high expectations, since they have pushed prices higher.
There are certainly exceptions to this as well as most rules for valuing a company, however you must recognize that finding a growth company that “nobody else” has found yet, would be extremely rare.