Berkey Creamery, the ice cream store located on the Penn State campus, had a phallic looking ice cream called “Sandusky Blitz.” described on their web site as “banana flavored ice cream with chocolate covered peanuts and caramel swirl". It is no longer on their menu as of the story breaking.
So everyone at the Creamery was in on this as well, huh? Boy...they sure know how to keep a secret all these years.
Come to think of it, Ben and Jerry got their start with a correspondence course from the PSU Creamery. Maybe they’re in on it as well.