To each his own I guess. I loved it. Saw it twice.
I HATED the movie. Almost every facet of the story had HUUUUUGE holes.
The film's only positive was the special effects. These were truly stunning in IMAX 3D.
If I hadn't paid extra, but saw it in just standard format, I would have REALLY hated the movie. Special effects and the IMAX 3D formatting brought my grade of the movie up to a C-. Without IMAX 3D, this movie merited a solid D.
I too enjoyed it and for cinema think you just go to be entertained.
If you want perfection in data etc. Just go watch a documentary or read a history book
Sci Fi is that.. grown up fairy tales that take your imagination fun places.
I can’t disagree with the reviewer just think that super analysis can ruin a lot of things (including relationships!)