It appears, from the n00b poster’s posting history, that to mislead/knit chaos is the poster’s intent. When a poster slaps a fellow freeper with a clearly erroneous definition (Black’s definition cannot be the most accurate, for the reason you so clearly identified), you know you’re dealing with a dissembler.
I used to find myself going "Huh?" when I would read what some people had written on this issue. Now I realize that throughout the internet there is a cadre of agent provocateurs attempting to intentionally spread bad logic and disinformation, and most of the time they are hiding behind legalistic pseudo logic. I now confront them with the silliness of their own assertions. This is a battle for reality over illusion, and we need to win it.