[MomwithHope]

Just came from seeing it. Loved it with one exception. I didn’t care for the ending. I preferred the John Wayne ending when he takes her home and then jumps the fence as he says goodbye. To all of a sudden cut to an older Maddy with one arm, well she just wasn’t that good and no Jeff Bridges in the final scene. Felt cheated. That movie deserved a happier ending.

[Cpl. Dwayne Hicks]

I think the Coen ending sticks with the book (I haven't read the book), so that's why we have a armless Maddie.

Also, I assume the book has Rooster in the Wild West show the movie references but to me, that isn't believable. A Rooster 24 years older than when we last saw him in the movie probably couldn't ride a horse, much less do shooting tricks.