( Michigan ) Battle Creek girl bags 448 lbs. black bear on hunting trip

The Enquirer ^ | 9/28/2010 | Matt Campbell

[caver]

“yet over and over we have posts of dogs killed by chainsaws, and an never-ending supply of animal-abuse stories”

100% total BS.

[Think free or die]

Good for her!

[absolootezer0]

This board, as I was led to believe, was a grassroots political conservative give and take forum, to exchange views and opinions

yeah. so if you don't agree with someone, make a rational arguement, preferably one that doesn't include a statement like "grow a pair."

[cripplecreek]

I’m thinking its time for a troll hunt.

[cripplecreek]

Hunting is kind of a rite of passage for most Michiganders outside of Detroit, Ann Arbor, and Kalamazoo.

I don’t hunt anymore but if the economy continues down this road I’ll be back out in the woods with something more than a camera.

[jellybean]

An 11 year old boy bagged a 737 lber over the week-end in my area - Hunter, 11, bags massive bear here. May be the state record.

[gigster]

I think DefeatCorruption went into her hidey-hole. Send in the Viking Kitties to search.

[cripplecreek]

Its not real sporting but we could set traps all around the entrance to its den.

[Ditto]

Hunting is NOT a sport. In a sport both sides should know they are in the game.

Are you crazy? The girl had a bow and was only 16 yards from a 400+ pound bear. If she missed, or just winged that bear, it could cover those 16 yards in about 2 seconds and rip her head off with one swipe of its paw.

That is sport.

[DefeatCorruption]

Hunting is NOT a sport. In a sport both sides should know they are in the game.
**********************************************************
Are you crazy? The girl had a bow and was only 16 yards from a 400+ pound bear. If she missed, or just winged that bear, it could cover those 16 yards in about 2 seconds and rip her head off with one swipe of its paw.

That is sport.
***********************************************************

Many people consider hunting and fishing as violent and the premeditated killing of wild animals and this is the first reason for which hunting and fishing cannot be accepted as a sport and, in fact, The International Olympic Committee has refused to include hunting and fishing as a sport. The basic rules of modern “sport” excludes any violence or killing against other persons or animals. Call it what you want, but it’s not a sport. A sport doesn’t kill anybody or anything.

Let’s just agree to disagree as there will never be a happy solution between anti-hunters and hunters. And yes, I am a conservative, Christian, pro-life and own a gun...and rarely eat meat, maybe a couple of times a year, and hate fish so never eat it. I don’t know what a vegan is, but suppose I could look it up.

The article caused an extreme visceral reaction and yes, I may be overly sensitive where animals are concerned, but I realize some of my remarks were uncalled for and for that I apologize to all who were offended.

[Osage Orange]

So, can we assume you are a PETA member?

[Osage Orange]

Do YOU consider fishing to be violent?

[Osage Orange]

When you do eat meat.....how is that meat prepared?

And you have no idea what a vegan is?

I raised two kids....basically vegetarians.

You probably cannot tell me much...

[Darren McCarty]

I just lost all respect for your post here.

and rarely eat meat, maybe a couple of times a year?

So you do eat meat. You just want others to kill the animal. Out of sight. Out of mind. Willfull blindness, offed in a much less humane way than a hunter.

Do you have the same protest when a dog kills a squirrel? Wolves and moose? Cats and birds?

People are part of nature. That's how it is. If you don't hunt, that's your business, but stay the hell out of this girl's way.

[SunkenCiv]

with a Matthews Passion bow and arrow set, designed for women, from a little over 16 yards away

Okay, that does it, I'm joining a health club.

[Tainan]

Sir/Ma'am, your beliefs are sound and your standing by those principles is admirable.
Your apology is a most gracious action; it continues to speak well for you. You would be less had you not voiced your sincere beliefs in this topic. Well, maybe not "less"...but we would not have had the exposure to sincere, sound and thought out beliefs by a fellow conservative on this topic.

Be well and prosper.

[Think free or die]

"Hunting is kind of a rite of passage for most Michiganders outside of Detroit, Ann Arbor, and Kalamazoo."

Yup. I grew up in Kazoo. My 90 year old dad still hunts in southwestern Michigan. He lives to hunt and fish.

[Ladysmith]

I hear that, trying to do that now with fish. Caught five one day, caught my limit the next, brother and I cleaned them, fried them up and ate them all with another brother’s help that night.

Not a whole lot going into the freezer *that* way!

[DoorGunner]

>>”The basic rules of modern “sport” excludes any violence or killing against other persons or animals.”

Be pleased to consider “Olympic Boxing.”

DG

[DefeatCorruption]

>>”The basic rules of modern “sport” excludes any violence or killing against other persons or animals.”

Be pleased to consider “Olympic Boxing.”
****************************************************
You’ve done your homework...so you know boxing is the only partial exception among the “official sports”, but rarely, if ever, results in death - and all parties are willing, competing athletes. In the animal world competition is not for pleasure, fun or profession. (some would argue except for cats of course).