[armydoc]

Nobody. They have always existed.

The laws of physics existed before there was any space, time or energy to be subject to them? Ah, yes, you mean that they existed in God's mind, of course. I agree completely.

[rahbert]

I said nothing about G*d’s mind.

You put words in my mouth.

[rahbert]

also, there is no way to prove G*d has or had a mind
or even whether one exists or ever existed.

the question is totally in the realm of faith.