My advice? As soon as you get off the plane, walk to the ticket counter and book a flight to Chicago...for there is no pizza in NYC worth wasting your time on! ;)
regards,
Chicago pizza isn’t pizza, its a Chicago invention (another problem). It’s not bad if you like a super thick crust and then don’t mind feeling bloated and want to split your gut open an hour later.
My personal favorite, http://www.delorenzostomatopies.com/