Not sure if they still have what you are looking for; but you can buy all the Cabot goodies at their on-line store...I generally avoid doing business with Vermont, but they sell a cheddar shake that we put on popcorn that is to DIE for. Cabot introduced it years ago, calling it ‘Shake’. They discontinued it, and there was so much hell raised (including yours truly) that they re-launched it under a different name. They still sell it to this day...
Vermont has a maple smoked that we by once eery couple of years...We’re blessed with AMish cheese nearby.