Why is the fat guy still fat?
If you've watched any of the seasons, Hurley still being fat is the least begging of the implausible scenarios.
Because Hurley is just that awesome! LOL
My theory...... Hurley used his lottery winnings to buy an island and set up all these scenarios just for a power trip....In the end Hurley will be sitting in a room drinking scotch watching TV monitors showing how he is in control....HAHAHAHA just kidding folks