IMO, it appeared that Garcia knew ahead of time he was going home. He moved too effortlessly into position to sing one last time and it wasn’t Hound Dog. I think AI is tinkering with their rules and format this year. IMO, GARCIA KNEW.
Yeah he didn’t seem too surprised to be leaving. Katie on the other hand seemed distraught.
He had to know there was a good chance that he was going home. I'm glad he didn't sing Hound Dog, lol. For the first time, Idol is letting the losers sing-out with a song of their choice. That's fair.