But somehow, Mac-Haters end up here.
Some of us are just technophiles, and love discussing computer and technological advances, and Apple is responsible for a significant number of technical innovations. I don't think the iPad is one of them, but love having an honest discussion about whether the device will catch on. But anytime the discussion is about an Apple product the there's a group that shows up to establish a categorical defense about the product simply because it's Apple.
To echo you, that is an honest response.
Furthermore, I think iPad is a gamble. It will pay off ... or not. I’m probably going to wait for the second generation.