[Greysard]

They [intelligentsia] will work for whatever is being paid when the going gets tough.

Well, when the going is really tough they will want to get those jobs. However compare the following candidates:

1. A US citizen, PhD, specialist in nuclear physics. Age 48. Hard labor experience: none. Weight lifting ability: 20 lbs. Awareness of his labor rights: full. Speaks English fluently, can lecture and write books. Can solve tensor calculus problems in his sleep.
2. A temporary immigrant, citizen of Elbonia. Specializes in loading railway cars. Age 22. Hard labor experience: extensive. Weight lifting ability: 250 lbs. (each hand.) Awareness of his labor rights: minimal. Speaks English with a dictionary. Heard about the pythagorean theorem once, but never needed to know any details.

Obviously the immigrant is a better hire. He won't be bored at the job because it's on his gamma level. He won't ask for his rights because he isn't aware of any. And he is young and strong.

Fact is, engineers and scientists make poor farm workers. They aren't used to hard labor; many of them are old. They'd need to work for *less* money than an immigrant to get the job. This is not very likely.

In any case, it is wasteful to have millions of top notch specialists and send them to work the fields. That is reminiscent of policies of Mao and Pol Pot. Those "geniuses" had no use of educated people. Do we need to follow in their footsteps, to fail just like they did? You can't rebuild the wealth of the USA if all your industry is farms. The government should work on bringing high tech industry back into the USA.

[Lumper20]

I agree with you based on the facts you presented.

Where are these unemployed PHD Physics? I damn sure do not know of a single unemployed PHD in engineering MGMT.

If you know of these people, I feel certain I can get them six figures and full benefits.