Replies

Judge Carter rejected the DOJ contention that quo warranto did not apply to the POTUS. Carter affirmed Donofrio’s contention that it did and the the DC Circuit was the proper venue.

Are you disagreeing with Judge Carter's affirmation of Donofrio on this point?

While some of Donofrio’s followers get a bit cult-like I personally have challenged him on numerous occasion on his blog, some of which he allowed in and some he screened out.

For example I told him that his whole NBC premise would fail if there was no Dunham-Obama marriage to transmit UK citizenship to BHO II under the 1948 BNA. He snipped my comment, but not without accusing me of smearing Obama. Then I reminded him that in “Dreams” Obama himself speculated that his parents might not have been married.

Soon after that, Donofrio developed a keen interest in the birth and marriage vital record index in HI and the marriage index was found, which elated Donofrio.

I then had the cheek to suggest that BHO Sr's marriage to Kezia might make the HI marriage bigamous thus blocking dual citizenship for BHO II. But Donofrio insisted that it was legally sufficient to ignore that and rely on Obama’s “admission against interest” that BHO Sr. was his father and the claim by his campaign that Obama was “governed by the BNA of 1948.”

Then I said Obama would probably throw the 1948 BNA under the bus and claim that his parents marriage was bigamous, if it would save his NBC status.

So you can see, I am not a Donofrio cult follower.

What I am hoping to come out of Donofrio’s quo warranto is discovery of the HI vital records which Obama might be compelled to release. I am sure Obama will fight release all the way and claim the short-form is sufficient.

In my view, the only threat to Obama’s NBC status is evidence in the HI vital records that shows a Kenya birth prior to amendment, or a report of a home birth that could, if false, allow for a Kenya birth .

This could take a long time and be a very long shot. It will all depend on how long Obama can delay discovery of the HI vital records.

Quo warranto is only available in DC. That’s the law. Carter correctly stated the law.

I’m not sure that the DOJ said it did not apply to POTUS. What was alleged to have been said in Carter’s court and what is in the transcript is often two entirely different things.

You keep referring to Donofrio’s quo warranto case. Where is it? Is he going to file it this decade?

.......BHO Sr's marriage to Kezia might make the HI marriage bigamous thus blocking dual citizenship for BHO II. But Donofrio insisted that it was legally sufficient to ignore that and rely on Obama’s “admission against interest” that BHO Sr. was his father and the claim by his campaign that Obama was “governed by the BNA of 1948.”
..... Obama would probably throw the 1948 BNA under the bus and claim that his parents marriage was bigamous, if it would save his NBC status.

I think you have hit upon at least one key motion in Team Obama's "Fall-Back" defense strategy! Since this is going to take years to percolate, perhaps we ought to turn our attention to Bobby Jindal's NBC status. Neither of his parents were citizens at the time of his birth in Lousiana!

BTW, I found it amazing that this past Fall, Donofrio developed a very keen interest in matters Hawaiian. It just doesn't get any weirder than the "The Case of the Man With No Past." Can anyone get this done? A Lawyer who's day job is Professional Poker Player? A beautiful Russian-American Lady Dentist? Mr. Keene, Tracer of Lost Persons?

I recommend that we refer the entire matter to the Supreme Court of the Republic of Honduras, after arresting and flying the Prepostor to Costa Rica, of course. The SCOTROH at least had the know-how to get rid of an unconstitutional President. Also, and hopefully, presumably gallant Latino jurists would give the pretty but cranky Dr. Orly at least the time of day, no matter how serious her many legal shortcomings.