Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

To: steelyourfaith
I especially enjoy the old time radio comedy writing. The writers did not have the luxury of falling back on sight gags or being augmented by visual slapstick, yet it was frequently very witty.

Depending on the show in question, they had a slightly deeper challenge---timing and placing the aural gags and audio slapstick, which is often a lot more difficult to bring off successfully. With the right sound people, attuned to the nuance of the characters and the rhythm of the dialogue (the sound people working such shows as Fibber McGee & Molly, The Great Gildersleeve, The Fred Allen Show, for example), the aural gags enhance and amplify the verbal humour, and the best comedy writers knew how to work with those as characters in their own right.

They had a challenge even deeper than that, if you take seriously the observation of one of the genre's absolute masters, Goodman Ace (Easy Aces): "A lot of times, on the air, I noticed comics in a sketch do a joke that destroys the character because it gets a big laugh." You could say that that knowledge was a key in making the quieter comedies---Easy Aces, Amos 'n' Andy, Vic & Sade, The Goldbergs (though it was always an open question whether this show was as much if not more a drama), Lum & Abner---endure as they did; to a one, almost, any of them that were converted to the half-hour sitcom format (as all but The Goldbergs were in their final radio years) lost too much in the conversion.

Ace himself conveyed the frustration when describing what CBS did to a show he'd worked up for Robert Q. Lewis (an occasional Easy Aces/mr. ace and JANE guest performer): "I give them a good, tight fifteen-minute comedy show and what do they do? Bring in an orchestra and an audience. Who the hell said a comedy show had to be half an hour? Marconi? Ida Cantor?"

An irony: Fibber McGee & Molly went the other way beginning in 1953: from a half-hour show with audience and orchestra to a fifteen-minute offering without the audience and orchestra. Having everything that survives of their show (and a boatload of it has survived), I can tell you the fifteen-minute, semi-serial version of the show is just as funny as the original half-hour. And the absence of audience probably allows the joke to grip a little more firmly, if a little more gently.

23 posted on 12/27/2009 11:04:16 PM PST by BluesDuke (Let sleeping dogs lie, and you leave them open to perjury charges.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 10 | View Replies ]


To: BluesDuke
I enjoyed that very much. Very interesting. Thanx ! I am of the opinion that the radio comedy writing itself was often very good in how the writers might set up a comical moment, and often using clever turns of phrase. Again, I am of the opinion that this caliber of writing carried through into early television sitcoms, and is largely absent today. I'm not sure I can remember a TV comedy show that I have cared to watch since the early 1970s.
24 posted on 12/28/2009 4:39:33 AM PST by steelyourfaith (Don't start the revolution without me.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 23 | View Replies ]

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article


FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson