What takes him out of the ball game is the “natural born citizen.” He has loyalties to the US as well as Britain/Kenya.
There will be those who will claim the SCOTUS hasn’t made a determination on “natural born citizen” and whine that good ol’ Chester got by with it so Hussein should get a pass as well. Through the decades, long before Birthers, the accepted definition of “natural born citizen” that took it a step further than “native born” was that both parents be US citizens.
Thus from “square one,” Obama is NOT a natural born citizen since his father is a Kenyan (then a British colony).
I'd like to see Barry out of office this minute and anything that accomplishes that is fine with me.
But I like speculating on things so let's just entertain this question to see where the tangent leads. Nothing personal so don't get offended. It's just for discussion.
Hypothetical: a woman- US citizen- gives birth to a baby in a hospital in the USA. They go to fill out the birth certificate for the baby. They ask her 'who was the father?'. Now, in my hypothetical, Jane Doe was a real slut and, LOL, it turns out she had been drunk and did the football team- one of whom was a foreigner. It could be one of like 22 guys and there is a small chance the father could be a foreigner.
What nationality does the baby have? Would the baby be eligible to run for President of the USA? Would we require the baby get a DNA test to prove he/she wasn't the offspring of the foreigner? If the foreigner was the father but the baby never met him would the baby have 'loyalties' to the father's country?
There's a whole can of worms you can get into here and I think these questions are interesting and in a way these questions are relevent to the discussion here.