I loved it, and was weaned on the original - I thought Spock (old) was tastefully handled and considered it for what it was - cheap entertainment
You want a story - read moby dick
My whole family liked the new Star Trek, and my son, husband and I love Lost!!!!!
Lost is a good complicated story, and Star Trek is an action packed movie. Both are good.
I saw it with my children (my husband refused to watch anyone but Shatner) I really enjoyed it. I cringed everytime **spoiler** Uhura kissed Spock, because I kept thinking “this is Sylar and he will KILL you!”
Or watch Ricardo Montalban in "The Wrath of Khan"...:)