[joma89]

That is one person’s opinion. Ignore the “man behind the curtain” and make your own decision on whether or not she is a good singer.

JoMa

[Peter Horry]

“That is one person’s opinion. Ignore the “man behind the curtain” and make your own decision on whether or not she is a good singer”

I haven’t seen her, except for the snippet that was on the news but I liked what I heard. A good singer is someone who can “touch” you with a song, they don’t need training to do that, but they will mostly improve with training and experience. Elvis and the Beatles were well into their careers before they were accomplished artists.

Arthur Smith (Dueling Banjos) told a story of working with Bob Wills on a recording a session, when someone came in and wanted them to listen to a demo tape. After listening to the tape, Wills said, hell the boy can’t even keep time .... that demo was by Hank Williams.

[Lazamataz]

That is one person’s opinion. Ignore the “man behind the curtain” and make your own decision on whether or not she is a good singer.

[MosesKnows]

Ignore the “man behind the curtain”

Exactly! I believe this person confuses production values with talent.