My take on it is that Jason is not truly in love with either one of them.
Will check back in for your reactions tonight.
My take on it is that Jason was enjoying a night with Melissa one night and Molly the next so much that he didn't want to have to quit "being in love" with both of them, and when he had to choose the final night, whichever he chose, he would still want to be with the other one, too. I think he chose Melissa because she appeared to be the perfect one to spend the rest of his life with, weighing everything about the two. I don't think he wanted real life to set in and he couldn't get the excitement of Molly out of his mind.
Maybe he should move somewhere that it's not all that uncommon to have two wives, however illegal it is. BLEH!
Jimmy Kimmel last night was funny, but in all fairness, Jason took the kidding well. :)