If I have choice between Brent Farve or Kurt Warner, I would pick Kurt..
Kurt’s great. And he’s a great guy. And I think he’s great for the sport. But no way is he better than Peyton Manning. It’s arguable that Tom Brady is better than Peyton Manning, even though I think he is.
When he is healthy, he might be the best in the bizness.
Get real. Brett Favre had no injuries, he always had to play with a mediocre OL and receiving core. He holds nearly all the QB records. Yeah he made boneheaded decisions and interceptions, but that's a plus, not a minus. That meant he wasn't afraid to take risks. Meanwhile Warner completely stunk from the Rams' SB loss to the Patriots in 2001 up until beginning of this season. He was ran out of St Louis in favor of Bulger and he was benched in AZ and only started because of injuries to the other QBs. Warner is nothing more than a Dave Kreig, a streaky, hot and cold QB. Is he Hall of Fame material? Yeah, he is I'll concede that.