[Dr. Frank fan]

As far as not catching the others, they were never tested.

Well, maybe you're right. Maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.

So if the Detector not catching them is the basis for the writers not being "consistent," I don't see it.

It's not "the" basis. It was one among many. Maybe it turns out not to be a contradiction after all. That leaves many others.

[highball]

"As far as not catching the others, they were never tested."

Well, maybe you're right. Maybe my memory is playing tricks on me.

"So if the Detector not catching them is the basis for the writers not being "consistent," I don't see it."

It's not "the" basis. It was one among many. Maybe it turns out not to be a contradiction after all. That leaves many others.

Okay, so let's have them. We can address them one by one.