You’re the one starting with the unsupportable comments. I’m thinking you’d soil your pants riding shotgun with my buddy at the wheel of, say, a C6 or a 911.
CR is geared towards the Middle America non-enthusiast driver, and works very hard at producing an impartial test.
C&D, R&T, and Automobile are all geared towards enthusiast drivers and, perhaps more importantly, their advertisers.
You’d have to expect some differences in output. Slamming CR because of that, with pure ignorance about their testers, is foolish. Both magazine types have their place.
Oh, and how supportable are yours?
"I’m thinking you’d soil your pants riding shotgun with my buddy at the wheel of, say, a C6 or a 911."
You would be guessing wrong, I expect you would be the one soiling your pants if I took you on a ride .
Whoo, a 911? give me a break, try driving something at the limit from the 60's.
This conversation is going nowhere, Consumer Reports will always be a joke as will Motor Trend.
Talk to the hand.
Bye!