Boy, those kids pretty much butchered Neil Diamond. That was rough. At least Brooke won't be around next week to soft-piano-ize some Jerry Lee Lewis or whatever.
I really liked Brook and her style of singing.
I wanted to see her do some Judy Collins, Joni Mitchell or Carly Simon.
Can you imagine her doing Circle Game?
Wow...now THAT would be a hell of a song for her!
By the way, I thought it totally bizarre that idol didn’t address the fact that the judge’s comments are written for them beforehand, and their comments have little to do with the actual performance of the song...
Ed