I have a friend with record industry ties and she said they’d never let him win Idol b/c of his age...starting a career that late at that age nowadays just doesn’t ‘sell’ as well, especially for Idol.
I did think he had potential to be the dark horse into the top 5...it was the DC thing and going first that killed MJ this week I think. Besides, they saw him as their expendable “other favorite” (out of DC/DA/C/B with MJ next up) and a wake-up call but one who’s elimination saved Carly.
Wonder if Carly really had the least votes and she was saved as she is Randy’s pet. Think about it...MJ was competition for their other pets DC and DA, too.
I did think he had potential to be the dark horse into the top 5...it was the DC thing and going first that killed MJ this week I think. Besides, they saw him as their expendable “other favorite” (out of DC/DA/C/B with MJ next up) and a wake-up call but one who’s elimination saved Carly.
What does this say about Carly and Cook? They are closer to MJ's age than Monchichi's age... Honestly, I think the fix is in. Monchichi wins and it doesn't matter what anyone else does...