Heads up to Motley Girl 70!!!
Sexiness can come in all forms (at least for me) from within when I view the opposite sex. Such as a man's sense of humor to intelligence to mannerisms. It's all subjective but it's little things like these that I find sexy in a man.
That said, if I were SJP I would hardly get upset about a poll taken by a bunch of knuckleheads that read Maxim.